The Arte vs. Vista Residences Part 1
A couple of readers have expressed their interest in the two new residential projects: The Arte and Vista Residences. To kill two birds with one stone, I decide to do a write up on these project since they are pretty similar in nature. The Arte and Vista Residences are both located at the Jalan Dusun; both developed by big property player; they are of 2 residential towers of 35/36 storeys, and they both boast unit views towards MacRitchie Reservoir and city views.
The Arte by CDL
Vista Residences by Far East Organization
The Arte by City Development Ltd is sitting at the site belonged to the old apartment blocks of Lok Cho Apartments, Comfort Mansion and the walk-up apartment block along Jalan Raja Udang off Balestier Road. City Developments Ltd had altogether snapped up a total of eight sites in en bloc purchases in 2006 and 2007, which also included The Albany, Thomson Mansions and Concorde Residences on Thomson Road; as well as Bright Building, Balestier Court off Balestier Road. (Another project Cube 8 is occupying the sites of the Albany & Thomson Mansions).
The Arte is ‘so-called’ designed by the renowned SCDA Architects led by principal Chan Soo Kian. The firm is known for its upscale condominiums like Nassim Park Residences, BLVD, The Ladyhill, and The Marq on Paterson. However I found no trace of the SCDA architectural style, sleekness and elegance in its harsh and bulky design. (Actually I was informed that the nature of the construction contract is actually a Design & Build by the main contractor, and SCDA was only assigned of the design concept, not the project implementation. However I have yet to verify this statement. If you have any information on this, kindly drop me a note on this.)
VISTA RESIDENCES is another residential project by Far East Organization, designed by TAA architect. It is sited on a 120,000sqft, L-shaped piece of land, which is just directly next to the Arte. If I could recall correctly, the site used to be occupied by rows of terrace housing. ( I should have the foresight to take photos of these places before they were gone… Things are just happening in Singapore so fast that you have to record them down so you are sure that they were actually there before……)
For your easy reference, I have done up a comparison table for your easy perusal:
| Development | The Arte @ Thomson | Vista Residences |
| Property | Condominium | Condominium |
| Developer | City Developments Limited | Far East Organization |
| Tenure: | Freehold | Freehold |
| Expected Completion: | 2010 | 2015 |
| # of Units: | 336 | 282 |
| Unit Types | Larger units available only:2 bedroom ~ 1,055 sqft3 bedroom ~ 1,399 – 1,625 sqft4 bedrooms ~1,873 – 1,873 sqft | Variety of sizes of units available:1 bedroom ~ 646sqft 2 bedroom ~ 926sqft 3 bedroom ~ 1109-1249sqft 4 bedroom ~ 1292-1313sqft Penthouse ~ 3229-3519sqft |
| Number of Storeys | 2 towers of 36 storeys | 2 towers of 35 & 36 storeys (2 tower blocks are almost as tall as a typical 44-storey since the 2nd level starts at 7th storey) |
| Architect | SCDA | TAA Architect |
Pricing
Project launched prices would be very much determined by the economic condition of the period, therefore the project launch date. Let’s take the Arte as an example: It was launched in early 2009 when the economic sentiment was still very poor. Therefore CDL took a price slash and launched it at an average of $900 psf . It was a hit and many units were sold. The developer also offered buyers an interest absorption scheme (IAS) initially, however it was not revealed how many buyers took it up. Today, all units have been sold out.
Few months later, Vista Residences was launched in a much improved economic condition. Therefore the launching price also shot up to an average of $1000 psf, which we are talking in terms of more than 10% more than the Arte though they were just 3 to 4 months apart in terms of the launching date.
As to date, many subsale units at the Arte were transacted at more than $1100 psf, while Vista Residences are seeing many transactions close to $1300 psf. We are definitely seeing the high optimism and exuberance in the property market.
Location & Accessibility
Thought both developments are sitting in the Balestier areas, both projects have been marketed as ‘exclusive developments located in the Novena & Thomson precincts’. Though it is with no denial that Novena & Thomson sound more premium in terms of its precinct due to its location, the developers should faithfully believe in its development’s intrinsic location rather than sounding up gimmicky marketing gestures to consumers. After all, Balestier’s image has very much improved with URA’s effort to clean up the sleazy trades it used to have. In addition, there are so many things and features unique about Balestier that we Balestierians are so proud of: its history and architecture, and its popular food streets and its everything. (Sorry, the marketing acts of the developers have somehow hurt the super ego of the Balestierian like me….)
Both projects are sharing Jalan Datoh for access. Due to its proximity to the highway, the area is highly accessible to all parts of Singapore. However Jalan Datoh is relatively a narrow single direction road with PIE filter into Balestier, the road will be relatively jammed up especially during the peak period and after more than 600 new families moving in after the Arte & Vista Residences are completed. It applies to the adjacent Balestier Road and Thomson Road as well.
Nearest MRT Station
Regardless of the market lines telling you that the Arte & Vista Residences are just steps away from Toa Payoh MRT station, you have to walk at least 15 minutes to reach the Toa Payoh MRT Station under no continuous shelter linkway and exercise by walking up the slope to reach the destination. I would suggest that taking bus down to Novena MRT station is much a better and faster option for the end users.
New Balestier Skyline
I also hold high anticipation to the new skyline these new developments, including Cube 8 is going to change the outlook of Balestier. This must be quite an exciting view if you driving past PIE viewing towards the Balestier area, with beautiful sleek skyscrapers fronting the gantry towards District 12.
To be continued with Part 2
If you are interested in Balestier’s intriguing history and on-going events, you are welcome to join us at the Facebook Living in Balestier.













Hi Keith
Another insightful comparison of Arte vs Vista Residences. Looking forward to Part 2. I actually did a check on the number of apartments that were enbloc on the Vista site. These included De Angelo, Datoh Court, Prince Apartment, Cai Yuan Mansion, Sapphire. Seems like Far East would have paid a much higher price for the plot of land compared to the price which CDL had paid for Lock Cho and Comfort Mansion. So perhaps it is reasonable that Far East had charged higher for Vista buyers. But Far East has always been known to charge higher price to buyers. Will be nice to make an analysis of how much profit Far East would have made even though it is still selling the higher floor bigger units.
Looking back, price seems cheap even at 1000 psf mid last year since now Balestier does not seem that cheap anymore with prices transacting around 1200 psf.
I am staying at an apartment in the vicinity of Vista and Arte and prices have been creeping up. Not sure if it is a good time to sell now?
Hi Michael,
Balestier property prices have shot up greatly, meeting the peak we had in 2007. Some properties I dealt with have actually surpassed the 2007 mark. If you are staying in the vicinity, I have to congrat you since you must have feel the asset getting more valuable. I do agree that the Balestier property is no longer ‘cheap’, catching up our adjacent neighbouring Novena.
To answer whether if is it a good time to sell:
1. Do you foreseen the new developments including the Zhong Shan Park is value adding to the place or the place is getting too crowded for your comfort? To me, Balestier’s location is always premium and it is possibly catching up high-end Holland V with its millionaire residents but in a more intriguing setting:)
2. If you are doing a downgrade or you own a separate property, I would say that the market is on your side. If you consider for upgrade, my advise is always be fully informed of your financial capability before committing to new loan. Sell high = buy high.
3. If you are cashing out the exisitng house to get a new loan for more investment, the current financing market especially the Sibor rate seems very attractive with its low interest rate. If you are able to find investment else place fetching higher return,(which could be easily done so), it may be a good time to sell.
There are many other factors involved, of course. Feel free to contact me if you need my service:)
Hi Keith
Thanks for your prompt response. I am not in a hurry to sell, just exploring the options I have. My opinion is that prices may appreciate some more in time to come esp the end of Balestier nearer to Thomson side. CDL has one more project to launch on the current Concorde Residence and price is definitely going to be higher than Cube 8. The Thomson MRT station on the circle line would be ready next year, giving another stimulus for price appreciation.
I was actually looking at the Arte and Vista for another property to invest though prices for both have already risen by quite a bit. But if we were to look back 4-5 years later, maybe the price now is still ok.
There’s another project by MCL, D’Mira at Boon Teck Road along Balestier which I believe is launching soon. I reckon the price will be >1000psf.
The D’Mira is formerly Boon Teck Heights. Believe it is soon to be launched, since my fellow collegues are already advertising for VVIP. It has 17 storeys and 65 units. Echo your same view, the launching prices should be more than 1000 psf:)
Leave your response!
keithyip
Click if you like what u reading:)
Project Adv
Search for homes?
Join us the Balestierians!
Syndicate
Subscribe to this site's RSS feed.
Most Viewed Posts
Recent Posts
Archives
Categories
Flickr
By Erik Rasmussen
Tags
Blogroll
Privacy Policy
Archives
Pages
Most Commented
Recent Posts
Project Adv
Search for homes?
Categories